The pizza seemed to be very standard for what you would expect for the price.
I felt like their salad and delivery went above and beyond, however. The salad ingredients, while simple, were very fresh and what I'd expect in a restaurant (though, the dressing itself was packaged). Additionally, it probably arrived in about half the time as estimated on GrubHub.
Edit: Since this review, I have ordered from Red Tomato Pizza multiple times. Generally, their pizza is about what you would expect. BUT their barbeque chicken pizza is probably the best pizza I've ever had. They make it completely differently. More toppings, better quality ingredients. I have no idea what explains the difference between the two types, traditional italian v. barbeque, but it's like a completely different restaurant makes it. It's seriously a must-try.
more