Great pizza, fun atmosphere and attentive staff.  I've tried to be a bit adventurous with their menu and have ordered some of their less traditional pizzas (Magical Mystery Tour etc) and while they're fun, they do seem to have a bit too much going on it them.  The classics or their white and pesto pizzas are really what they do best.  Cold beer, football playing at the bar (and sometimes a random dog show) make it a fun place to relax and let your guard down.  The occasional huge group of tourists will show up and stall the hostess, but overall- it's mostly SCAD students, families and young professionals that frequent the restaurant.  It's nice to get away from the tourists sometimes...
Pros:  Great pizza and hoagies
Cons:  Stay away from the less traditional pies
                        
more