top 10

Sicilia's Pizzeria

Claim
marker

181 Atwells Avenue
Providence, RI 02903

marker
1 (401) 273-9222
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Managed by Uberall
Main categories:

Italian Restaurants

Reviews
( 20 )
( 7 )
( 4 )
( 3 )
( 4 )

Best

Loved it! I'd order drunk or sober from here anytime. Get the Chicken Club Pizza sandwich...on 2nd thought, get 2. Your gf might wanna steal yours. *drops mic and walks away*

Worst

To the person who said ""this is true Chicago style, cut into squares not slices"" I realize that there are many places here in in Chicago that cut their pizzas in squares, but...

Editorial review from GrubHub 4/6/2014

by Muna at GrubHub Provided by GrubHub
Delivery was struggle. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from GrubHub 12/29/2013

Loved it! I'd order drunk or sober from here anytime. Get the Chicken Club Pizza sandwich...on 2nd thought, get 2. Your gf might wanna steal yours. *drops mic and walks away* more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from GrubHub 12/28/2013

Stuffed Spinach. For real. -(formerally) Chicago Dave more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/3/2013

Ive tried alot of Providences pizza. To be honest I have multiple favorites but for over 2 years now I dont think I could make it a month without atleast one craving needing to be satisfied more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from GrubHub 8/29/2013

very good I recommend it to those that like stuffed pizza more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 12/1/2012

Excellent food. Fast delivery. Would order from again. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 9/7/2012

the food was awesome and service was great more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 8/25/2012

Their regular crust pizza is delicious. Authentic tiramisu, the ladyfingers soaked in just the right amount of expresso. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 4/17/2012

We where given a 10 - 20 min pick up time, we ordered around 730pm and stopped by around 755pm, Hostess at the counter told us it would be another 15 minutes, it did not look like they even started the order until I walked through the door, when I came back 15 mins later the guy handing me the stuff was being rude about it like I should have waited inside for the full 15 mins instead of waiting outside for 10 mins. The items felt hot but when I got home the pizza tasted cold, like it was sitting around and reheated. I like 2 mins down the road so that would not have been a factor in it cooling down so quickly, hot box cold sauce. The food tasted great but a disappointing in the service for pick up, it was a slow Monday night the restaurant was empty, no excuses. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 3/30/2012

Sicilia's is an amazing Sub/Sandwich shop even though it is primarily advertised as a Pizza Shop. I HIGHLY recommend the steak and cheese sub. They are relatively fast with your order, never have messed up with my orders and have been generally very pleasant to work with. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 1/19/2012

Burger and fries were great! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from eat24hours.com 5/30/2011

First of all, when the delivery came it was missing part of my order. The delivery guy barely spoke English and did not seem to care that I didn't recieve my correct order. He did call the restaurant, but never made any effort to correct the mistake. I went back and checked my confirmation email, which had the complete order listed. I did call Sicilias to ensure that I would not be charged for the missing order. They never made an attempt to apologize for this screw-up. Also, the food wasn't very good. The pizza crust was bland and the pizza itself was not impressive. I will not be ordering from Sicilias again. more
Reply | Report abuse |

DO NOT ORDER FROM SICILIAS 1/15/2009

My boyfriend and I ordered from Sicilia's hoping to enjoy a nice, delivered meal. When he bit into his last slice, however, he bit into a piece of CHEWED GUM. The manager/owner would not listen to our complaint and actually accused us of chewing the gum and putting it on the pizza. Their customer service stinks and this restaurant is CLEARLY not up to health standards. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Extra Ingredients 1/15/2009

Loved this place until I got a piece of chewed gum added to my order, under the cheese. Called to complain and was told by management that I was trying to get myself a free $13 pizza. Stay away from these guys unless you don't mind sampling whatever extras they feel like adding to their product. Cons: expensive, slow, tampered with more
Reply | Report abuse |

Chicago style? Not really 9/6/2008

To the person who said ""this is true Chicago style, cut into squares not slices"" I realize that there are many places here in in Chicago that cut their pizzas in squares, but that is NOT ""Chicago style"" pizza. Chicago style is known as ""deep dish"", and it is cut into triangles. The pizza cut into squares is actually credited to St. Louis style pizza (or provel pizza) and it was invented by a man who layed floor tiles for a living. Saw that on a History Channel show about pizza. Chicago does have some pretty good thin crust (or flat pizzas), but it's not ""Chicago style"". If you want thin crust pizza, I mean really GOOD thin crust pizzas, you go to New Haven,. Phillly, New York, St Louis, or Milwaukee who has the unique ""cracker crust"" pizza baked on square cookie sheets. There is a place outside Milwaukee called Wells Brothers. It advertises the 'best thin crust pizza in the world"" and boy do they deliver! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from GrubHub 9/3/2008

by John at GrubHub Provided by GrubHub
They forgot my soda with the delivery. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from GrubHub 7/23/2008

Always on time with deliveries. Food is good. more
Reply | Report abuse |

""Avoid this place"" means not going back 7/10/2008

Pros: pizza Cons: other customers who tie up staff from promptly serving me more
Reply | Report abuse |

good 6/16/2008

pretty good pizza i had spent a vacation in providence/boston for a week recently and really like this place. try the veggie large crust!! Pros: yum Cons: kinda expensive more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Sicilia's Pizzeria


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Owner Message

  • Sicilias of Federal Hill frozen deep-dish pizza comes from one of Americas greatest Italian neighborhoods. This specialty pizza has been a Federal Hill favorite for over 30 years. In fact, we ship our pizzas across the country to customers who have left the area, but still crave our pizza. So began our take and bake frozen pizza recipe.

    Our bake-at-home pizzas are made with the same care and attention as the pizzas served at our restaurant on Providences Federal Hill. Each pie is handcrafted using the best ingredients: rolled, hand-tossed dough; generous handfuls of fresh mozzarella; and Sicilias fresh, specially made tomato sauce.

    The result is a hearty, classic Italian meal that features a soft cheesy center, a tangy savory marinara sauce and a light, crunchy crust that alone or with toppings creates a flavorful and filling meal that will satisfy even the heartiest appetite. Enjoy!

Additional information
  • Hours: monday: 10:00AM-02:00AM, tuesday: 10:00AM-02:00AM, wednesday: 10:00AM-02:00AM, thursday: 10:00AM-03:00AM, friday: 10:00AM-03:00AM, saturday: 10:00AM-03:00AM, sunday: 10:00AM-02:00AM
  • Neighborhoods: Federal Hill
badge