I've been to most of the steakhouses in NYC and Luger is the best steakhouse hands down. I think people go to Peter Luger having these grandiose, unrealistic expectations (as did I) and are disappointed when it fails to meet them. Yes, it is an institution. But it's still just a restaurant. And objectively, they have the BEST steaks, ambiance or no ambiance. I always have a fabulous meal every time I go. Be sure to leave room for schlag!
Pros: Excellent porterhouse, schlag, great value for the food
Cons: Hard to get a reservation, cash only policy
more