I had a good experience at Peter Luger. The waiters were nice and helpful. The porterhouse was amazing as advertised.
But I have to say, I'm a naysayer. I just prefer having a choice of what to eat. Not only is there very little on the menu besides steak, but you really have no choice of what cut of meat to get. Plus, I'm not real fond of the idea of sharing a steak. I want my own hunk of meat so I can slice it the way I want. The final negative here...the sides leave a lot to be desired and the sauce is revoltingly sweet.
That being said, it's a unique and memorable place and the steak is awesome. But you should be warned that you really have no choice in what to eat. I would not go unless you are a steak fanatic.
Pros: Awesome Beef, Reputation
Cons: Few Options on Food, Weak sides/apps
more