Why Not 2 Men Spa

Claim
marker

235 West 19th St
New York, NY 10011

marker
(212) 337-9880
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Day Spas

Related categories:

Personal Care

Photos
Why Not 2 Men Spa - New York, NY
Why Not 2 Men Spa - New York, NY
Videos
Reviews
( 18 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

This was a birthday gift and I will definitely be back. I went last weekend after a hard week at the office. By the end of my massage, I was calling it the best week of my life.

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Great Experience 9/20/2011

This was a birthday gift and I will definitely be back. I went last weekend after a hard week at the office. By the end of my massage, I was calling it the best week of my life. more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Better Experience Than Their Other Spa On West 4th 3/31/2010

This spa is a little better than their West 4th spa. The pedicure stations are cleaner and the spa it self seems to be run better. Pros: Cleaner bathroom and nice pedicure stations more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great massage and pedicure 7/26/2009

I went on short notice a week ago for a pedicure and decided to try a package that included a 45 minute massage. I was impressed by the detailed pedicure. I was expecting a mediocre but relaxing massage ... but received a wonderful, gentle but deep massage that loosened knots I didn't even realize were there. After 45 minutes I was so relaxed that I stumbled out of the room like a drunk. Andy, thank you. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Place 1/22/2009

I live in the neighborhood. A friend of mine gave me a Gift Certificate from Why Not Chelsea as Christmas gift. It was one of the best gift I have ever gotten. I had an hour massage, Green Tea Pedicure, and a Facial. I don't get these kind of treatment very often, all I know is that when I walked out of there that day, I was stree free and felt like a new person. It was a great gift to kick off the year. more
Reply | Report abuse |

I will definitely go back for it 1/13/2009

I went in for a manicure and pedicure, and they talked me into getting a facial. I got slam with a bill, but I have to say, the facial worth every signle dime I spent. I saw myself from ""before"" to ""after"". I told my friends, ""if you want to look good without going under a knife, go and try to get a facial at Why Not"". Seriously, it is that good. more
Reply | Report abuse |

FaCiAl 11/20/2008

Ok, I know this is a Men Spa, and I hope I am not getting anyone in trouble with this. The facial is so good, I have to say something about it. Yes, I am a girl, and I live in the area. I was deperated for a facial, I asked them to help me out; they did.\r I moved to NYC for 5 years now, I have been getting facial all over town, even Jersey. I can tell anyone, straight up, Sammy (that's their facialist) gave me one of the best faical ever! Girls, well.. and guys, trust me, go get a facial from this place. You will definitely become a regular there.\r Pros: Best Facial Ever!!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Romantic Anniversary 11/20/2008

It was me and my boyfriend's 3 years anniversary. I asked Why Not to cater an anniversary celebration for us. I heard it from a friend of mine, her friend had a Spa Birthday Party at Why Not, appearantly, they took care of everything, and the party was great. Including tips and tax, I spent a little under $500, and it was wonderful. We had wine and chocolate strawberries in a huge tub. After that, we had our couple body scrub session. And we finished off with sushi rolls and green tea with honey.\r We spent 2 hours there and it was a great anniversary for both of us!!! Pros: Great Service Cons: Need to work on the Sound Proof more
Reply | Report abuse |

Truly, a GREAT Spa 11/9/2008

I used to operate my own spa business when I was back in Ohio, I KNOW spa. Stumble upon Why Not one night, decided to give them a call the next day and give them a try. This is a upper middle spa, it is very Zen, and people were friendly and casual. I had a 60 min massage and deep pore facial package, both services were exceptional. The quality of their services are exactly what a spa should have. I talk to the manager up front, suggested him to set a bar/lounge area for the customers, turned out they already have plan to do so.\r I give them 8.8 out of 10 Pros: Facial and Massage Cons: Sound Proof wasn't that good more
Reply | Report abuse |

Amazing Foot Massage 11/8/2008

I treated myself a Spa Pedicure, and it was a wonderful experience. The Spa was quiet, and the music and the rose fragrance just completely relax my body. I asked for 30 min foot massage, HIGHLY RECOMMEND! I was amazed what a simple 30 min foot massage can do to my body. The staffs were very friendly and professional, all and all, it was a great spa experience. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Best massage therapist I had-Jackie 11/3/2008

Probably I tried more then hundreds spas around the US. And I have to tell you that the massage therapist Jackie is the best top three for my choice.He is very friendly, athletic ,and skilled .\r \r HIGHLY RECOMMENDED more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Spa Experience. 11/1/2008

My wufe surprised me with a gift certificate for a mani/pedi, facial and massage. From the moment I walked in the door of Why Not, I was amazed at the quality of service. The receptionist greeted me warmly and was very attentive to my needs. Not only did he bring me water and take my coat, he smiled and made eye contact with me. The massage was fantastic! The perfect amount of pressure and the right amount of time was spent on each part of my body. And the facial gave me at least 5 years back. I felt the effects of the day well into the evening. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Scrubzmazing! 11/1/2008

i just moved into the city for like 2 months. Went to Why Not for the first time yesterday and treated myself a full body scrub. I am very impressed with their homemade scrub. It was gentle and and smelled really good. I tried to buy some from them, but they were not for sale. However, they were kind enough to give me a jar of scrub, thank you! more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Great Gift 10/30/2008

My boyfriend was in town last week, I gave him an early birthday gift from Why Not. It was great, the guys were very helpful. He had a wonderful massage, and a manicure and a pedicure. They have this package for manicure and pedicure and 60 min massage for only $138, which is pretty good, if you ask me. Bottom line, he had a great experience, and I am happy about it. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Thank You Sammy!! 10/29/2008

I had a show to go on in one week, and my was tired because of all my partying. It looks dried, and the pores were all clogged. I walked by and saw Why Not's facial treatments, I gave it a try (and I was desperately indeed for a facial). \r It was AMAZING. I am no stranger to facial treatment, but I have never seen my skin being this fresh before. Maybe it was because of the products they use, I am not sure, but anyway, Thank You, Thank You, Thank You! Pros: Facial Cons: Honestly, I don't know. I didn't try other services. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Just Average 10/26/2008

i wanted to get my boyfriend a massage and pedicure for his birthday so I went to Why Not 2 Men Spa. This spa has two locations and both of them have different prices/specials. i was disappointed to find out the their location on West 4th was cheaper. B/c this was a gift to my boyfriend i was willing to pay a bit more so I booked the appointment at the 19th street location. \r The frontdesk gentlmen was nice, but spacey and didn't always answer my questions with a direct answer. The facility is a bit small. I asked if there was a locker room and the front desk gentleman told me there wasn't, but that each room had a massage table and a glass shower in it. Needless to say, when my boyfriend went for his spa day there was no shower in the room. He said the massage was ok.\r The place is just OK...nothing to rave about. I recommend Okeanos Spa on the upper eastside. My boyfriend has been there before and really enjoyed the experience. It's a big facility with a sauna, bar, showers, etc. Pros: quiet Cons: small facility, lackluster experience more
Reply | Report abuse |

One of the Best! 10/16/2008

I have been going to Why Not for over a few times. I used to go to other spas in the city, but have not returned to any of them because I am totally satisfied with the services I receive at Why Not. The owners and staff run a smooth operation and are constantly focused on quality. The massages I have received at Why Not have been consistently excellent. The amenities are great and the environment is serene and comfortable. The staff is always able to accommodate my schedule, which with my schedule is very much appreciated. This is the perfect place in the perfect location. I highly recommend Why Not Men Spa.\r \r more
Reply | Report abuse |

All Spa Should Be Like This 10/16/2008

This spa looks exactly as elegant as they show on thier pictures. And I like my massage from them, they have a specialty called TuiNa. It was amazing, it is how all massages should be. Everyone at the spa was so friendly and professional. I had a great experience. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Finally! 10/12/2008

It's so great to finally have a good spa open in Chelsea!! I have been going to Why Not for years now, they just open their 2nd location at Chelsea. The service is always perfect, and I walk out of there feeling like a new man!! \r Pros: Great Facial. Cons: Busy Place. Make appointment. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantastic Services 10/12/2008

I visited Why Not last month for the first time, I was very impressed. The front desk staff was very funny and courteous, and the team was in sync with each other, they make you feel comfortable the minute you step in. It was clean, I really did like the Buddah head in the back. However the best thing about this place got to be the services. I had the facial and masssage package, they were fantastic! Simply the best. I would recommend any of my friend to go visit Why Not. Pros: They don't chichat too much during the services, perfect! Cons: The choice of music was so so more
Reply | Report abuse |

Exceptional Services. 10/9/2008

It was a great massage I've got from Why Not. This place has a very Zen setting, yet not overwhelming. I had a very relaxing 90 min away from my busy schedule. I am looking forward to my next visit. more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Owner Message

  • WHY NOT MEN'S SPA is located in the heart of New York's West Village and Chelsea. You'll find yourself in an elegantly appointed, Zen sanctuary that imparts to all who enter an immediate sense of serenity and harmony. We are your resort spa to escape from the rigors city. In addition to our facials, manicures, pedicures and massage packages, we now offer spa packages as well. Spending some quality time in our spa , which is without equal to any other NY day spa or health spa, is bound to rejuvenate the senses.

Additional information
  • Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-12am Sun 12pm-10pm
  • Neighborhoods: Midtown, Chelsea
badge