The New Yorker

The New Yorker restaurant is an institution in Salt Lake City and for good reason! The menu changes seasonally, using the best ingredients available.Chef Pliler travels the country looking for inspiration for his menu, and the resultsare amazing! I don't know in what restaurant the previous reviewer dined, (back in 2009) but my guess s that they have no concept of what fine dining really is.\r \r I've been told that Chef Pliler checks every plate that leaves his kitchen (and by the way, Chef Pliler has never cooked in any of Gastronomy'sother locations). As for the lamps in the dining room, I am told they came from the old Hotel Utah, and I believe add a wonderful ambiance to the meal. The restaruant is not a ""dark, dank basement"" but it most defintely IS an elegant, upscale, long time favorite of Salt Laker's, providing consistgently delicious food in a relaxing atmosphere with professional service. Perhaps the previous reviewer should stick to the Spaghetti Factory, where the meals are cheap and all-inclusive, the menu is voluminously long, and servers spout their greetings by rote. more

I am a firm believer that a restaurant gets two chances. The New Yorker had its second chance last night and failed with flying colors. \r 1. The menu is small and has remained the same for 20 years little development and creativity.\r 2. They require servers to TELL you the specials and expect you to memorize all 3-4 dishes. \r 3. You are required to ask about the $28 inclusive menu; once again memorizing 3 choices. \r 4. Salad and soup and not included. The cheapest salad is $12 (Mixed greens with Blue Cheese, caramelized pecans with Balsamic Vinaigrette…sound like every other salad available in the valley: Creativity Zilch) Soup $6. \r 5. Entrees on the menu: Cheapest a grilled Chicken breast with Pasta $20; Most expensive Surf and Turf $45.\r 6. Lighting: Apparently the owners invest in some hideous Italian Crystal lamps for over the table $1500 each. Issue with lamps they hang so low over the table you cannot see the server so the server to compensate for the “road block” shimmies from side to side to make contact with customer. Before you know it you have boat rock.\r 7. This “acclaimed” Chef Will Pliler doesn’t even over see the dinners. We were told that he mainly spends time at the Market Street Restaurants in the South of the valley (Which according to our waiter once again are the restaurants generating revenue; perhaps staying around the NY would yield in quality control and more revenue). This means no oversight in the kitchen. And you can tell that cheap laborers are putting the dishes together, as indicated by soggy pasta and over cooked fish. (I even called this fact out to the waiter…who confirmed my suspicions.) The sous chef doesn’t take pride in details or oversight either; Why would he when the cheap laborers appear to have everything under control?\r 8. There is not ADA entrance. Sharp steep steps leading into a dark dank basement with remnant smell of fish from the Broiler above. \r 9. A meal for two people after purchasing salad/soup and an entrée is approximately $40 desert sold separately. \r If you would like to eat truly fine cuisine, with a Chef who puts pride into every meal personally, try Francks Restaurant (Soup and Salad included with entrée). If steak is your fancy, try Little America Steak House (Soup and Salad are purchased separately but at a nominal fee and with superb selection and creativity). \r Cons: Lack of Creativity, Overpriced, Bad Lightling, Terrible Food more

We were there in Thursday i hae see something interesant each day a new meniu in that day it was a meall... more

We were there in Thursday i hae see something interesant each day a new meniu in that day it was a meall called "Chicago Style Roasted Chicken wit... more

January 7th, 2007. Having enjoyed dining at The New Yorker over the years, it is disappointing to see a noticeable decline in ambiance, service and food during the past year. My most recent visit, anniversary celebration, was ""very average"" in all regards. \r \r The ambiance was lacking which, I would attribute somewhat to the table location in the Big Apple (unbearable dish/utensil noise and off-key serenade by the dish washer?) and excessive foot traffic due to the private party in the Wine Cellar. I had specifically requested a romantic table. \r \r The service was efficient, but cold, at first but steadily declined as the dinner progressed with the accumulation of empty plates, including the bread, longer gaps between stops, and for some reason, completed disinterest in refilling the water or wine glasses. The food, well, I must admit, I have never seen oysters as small as the ones presented for an appetizer. Also, I have never have had a fillet presented already sliced - so much for retaining the juices and heat and the horseradish potatoes, very sour and completely lacking any semblance of horseradish flavor. I guess the potatoes absorbed the juices from the steak. \r \r The wine, the selection is excellent but I have noticed on several occasions? considerable variability from bottle to bottle of the same vintage of very expensive wines. Buyers beware! \r \r Overall, the menu, service and friendliness of the staff are becoming tired and need refreshing! A very average experience at a not so average price is offered at this establishment. \r Pros: Wine List, appetizers and steaks Cons: Price more

I've dined at Gastronomy Restaurants for almost 20 years and was looking forward to spending New Year's Eve at the New Yorker with a few friends. Upon arriving 10 minutes early for our reservation we were told that a table wouldn't be available for another 30 minutes because the folks on our table had just started dessert. Then when we were finally seated we were told that there was a reservation on our table at 10pm - an indication that they expected us to be finished and out the door by then. Service was marginal at best. On a big night you'd expect slower service but we were all missing pieces to our place settings and had to wait for replacements, extra bread, and even tea bags when we ordered tea after dinner. The clincher came when a hostess arrived at our table with our coats in hand (!) as the witching hour approached and they wanted us off the table. I was aghast. I couldn't believe the nerve. The food was great but nothing that I'd write home about. The wine list was exceptional. Pros: Wine list Cons: The service was horrible. more

Trying out new restaurants in town is cool, but when I am in the mood to go somewhere where I know I'll be well taken care of and have consistently good food, the New Yorker is my favorite place. The hostesses are all hot (and are actually capable of having a conversation) and the bartenders are pretty chill. The key is to not be intimidated by the ultra fancy decor and just pretend you're among friends. If you don't feel like a big elaborate dinner, you can go casual - their burgers are awesome! Despite what I used to think about the place, there are actually some really good deals. The service can be a little slower on show nights when it's packed, but it's worth the wait. Pros: Friendly Staff, Good Food more

I've been a member of The New Yorker Club for over 25 years, and what was once a memorable experience has now become an expensive disappointment.\r Recently my family dined downstairs in the Cafe to be treated to what I call ""the best chicken fried steak in the world."" Their mashed potatoes used to be fabulous and the corn was freshly cut off the cob. This time, the potatoes were inedible due to over salting. The corn tasted spoiled or at least the taste was ruined by a tart seasoning, and the half-price appetizers have been discontinued. \r My hot fudge sundae appeared to have been made earlier in the evening and then defrosted upon ordering. For seven dollars it wasn't even worth finishing. \r Perhaps it is time for a change of chef, or at least a change. My equity card doesn't seem worth renewing.\r Pros: Valet parking, good service, excellent bar. Cons: Expensive valet parking, average food, high price. more

i was surprised to see this restaurant head the list of 'trendy restaurants'. i haven't gone here for awhile because i found it quite stodgy and the food was mediocre boring for an upscale restaurant. it was also very expensive - my advice, if you want something great and don't mind paying, go to the metropolitan. more

I have been a member of the New Yorker Club for 15 years. Every time I eat there I am amazed at thier ability to raise the bar on fine dining in Salt Lake City. I enjoyed a 4 course meal. My knowledgeable server recommended that I start with sauteed Foie Gras paired with a glass of semillion wine. Next, a fried soft shell crab salad with a glass of an Austrailian sauvignon blanc, only to be out done by a mustard crusted rack of lamb in a rosemary cream sauce with a glass of cabernet. The meal ended with a creme brulee with fresh berries and a glass of a 20 year old port. The service was impeccable, the ambience is elegant and the food perfect. It is by far the best dining experience that I have ever had. Of course, I've said this many times before. Well done. Pros: New glass wine carts, great mixed drinks more

The New Yorker is great!! The food has been wonderful everytime I've been there, and it's been alot. You can eat in the cafe if your in search of a terrific inexpensive dinner. The cafe menu had nothing over $20 and all the appetizers are half price before 6pm and after 9pm Monday thru Saturday and all night on Wednesdays. It's a great place to people watch and a wonderful atmosphere with all the marble, stained glass and extraordinary flower displays. The bartenders, Colter, Chris, Bobby and Daniel are all very friendly and great at their jobs, you never feel uncomfortable if your by yourself sitting at the bar, they make it a great experience. Definatly go to the New Yorker if you looking for an elegant dinner at a fair price in a beautiful restaurant. Pros: Service, Food, Beautiful restaurant Cons: no smoking more

When I'm spending $50 - $60 for a meal, I expect more than average, but that is just what we got at the New Yorker. The restaurant makes an attempt at elegance (beautiful stained glass), but comes up short with accoustic tiles for a ceiling. Service was average. Server was disinterested and not very attentive. Food was also average. Nothing was exceptional here. This restaurant seems a bit pretencious. Will not return, nor recommend. Cons: , Food, Ambiance more

Way over-rated. Poor service, and an unwelcoming attitude. Not worth the price or at any price. Pros: Nice setting Cons: poor service, unfriendly, over-priced more

We're not sure what the negative reviewers are talking about. Maybe they are not used to high-end dining. At the New Yorker, you get exactly what you pay for: excellent food and competent service. Rarely do you find that in Utah. Pros: food Cons: parking more

The New Yorker is to stuffy and milk toast for me. I can not believe that La Caille is not one of your best in town. I can enjoy a fabulous meal and feel like I am in the country. If I want New York atmosphere I would go to New York. I get treated much better in New York City. Pros: Okay Food Cons: Expensive, Stuffy, Snobbish more

If you haven't had one for awhile or would like something wonderful, try their pepper Steak it is the best I have every had!! more

I don't understand what these reviewers are talking about! I am a new customer to the New Yorker and I think it is absolutley grand! I had lunch there today...it was very busy...the waiter was a bit slow to bring the beverages but the manager saw the problem and fixed it right away and even sent us home with a complimentary dessert. Problems are going to happen but it's how the issue is resolved that matters to me. more

This is the hangout of the wannabes and self important SL crowd. Food is good, but not great, atmosphere is noisey and alcohol is overpriced. Pros: Nice bar area Cons: too crowded, overrated more

The Gastronomy restaurants are so overrated. They are usually very loud and the food is slopped on the plate. There is no interest in presentation. Pros: Nice building, prices, has a cafeteria feel Cons: waiter serve soup, waiters make salads, too much food more

I found the food very good, but the ambiance less than romantic. Too smokey (private club allows smoking in the dining room, and too loud. Pros: Food quality/Selectio, Location Cons: Loud, Smokey, Snooty Wait Staff more