My fiance had my engagement ring made by Katherine James at Calvin's, and not only is it the most beautiful ring (and often complimented), but Calvin's has been extraordinary on follow up service.  We got an incredible value on the ring, and it really is a dream.  I recommend Calvin's to everyone I know who might get engaged in the future because I really feel there is no better place in Austin.  I think that a five star average with almost 200 reviews speaks for itself.  Go to Calvin's - you won't be disappointed.
Pros:  customer service, quality, value, atmosphere
                        
more