We booked 4, 2-room "cabins" and 2 rooms for OBX Bike Week '09 and never regretted a moment of it. In fact, the trip was the absolute best I've ever taken and the TOI was a huge contributing factor in that. The owner was friendly and accomodating and the staff was couteous and professional. We're booking the same rooms for OBX '10.
Pros: hospitality, location
more