Unlike the nearby competition, Mystic Sweets Shoppe really does make all of the ice cream it sells. Local people shop there year round. In addition to the ice cream, the fudge and other goodies make a visit a delicious treat. During the summer when tourists are visiting, the line can get long; that's the only drawback.
Pros: Best ice cream in the area
Cons: Mystic, CT is popular with tourists; too busy in the summer
more