We ordered the All American (regular burger; no gimmick sauces or anything). The burger was just average; only a little better than a Sonic burger, but 3x as pricey.
The meat was grassfed beef, but did not have much flavor. Small machine pressed patty. The bun was nothing special, and the toppings were old. Our salad was wilted, and the water was bad. Only Pro was good service and choice of beef.
If you want to try Austin's best burgers, go to #14? Cover 3, #2 Counter Cafe, or #37 Mighty Fine (yes, a chain). Discovered these through Texas Monthly's Best 50 burgers in the state edition.
Pros: Choice of beef
Cons: Only average burger
more