I've fairly new to keeping fish (1 year now) but Wet Spot is my go-to-place. They have a pretty wide range of fish and accessories. The staff are knowledgable.....but lets just say that there's some that are even more knowledgable than others. Both combined to ensure that the fish you're buying are nice and healthy (they have a return policy too).
About the only downside is that the place is incredibly busy. If you're looking for advice/fish it's now unknown to wait 20-30 minutes to get help. Otherwise it's a great store.
Pros: Experienced staff, great selection, decent prices
Cons: On a weekend it gets busy and is hard to get served
more