My husband and I have frequented Blue Moon quite often since we moved to West Village. The staff has always been extremely friendly and knowledgeable (including host and bar staff). The pizza has the perfect amount of crunch, great sauce and fantastic ingredients. The wings are quite good and the salads are incredibly fresh.
The wine list isn't great- but I assume most people who go there grab a beer with their pizza.
Avoid Friday and Saturdays if you do not want to surround yourself with dozens (and dozens) of small children (and parents who don't care what their kids do/scream). The restaurant is just out of control with kids on the weekend.
Pros: Pizza, Salads, Location
Cons: Too. Many. Screaming. Children.
more