I'm a picky Italian, from the northeast, and this place offers great Italian food! The atmosphere, wait, and service are all part of the experience...but if a ""hole in the wall"", long wait, slow service aren't part of what you want with your excellent food, then try the sister restaurant Edo's Squid, which offers a similar menu but ""fancier"" digs. My favorites: scungilli, broccoletti, orecchietti, rockfish, and the ny strip steak...
Pros: Food, wine, atmosphere
Cons: Location, service
more