Went at 6pm on Saturday, it was already crowded but we just waited 10 minutes before we snagged a seat at the counter/bar. Average french fries. Burgers were good and done just the way we ordered, but they were nothing special (I could cook a burger at home that would be just as good as The Counter's). Service was lovely and fast. I will go back, but only because it is geographically convenient for me and I do like that you can customize how you want your burger. But otherwise, I would not drive out of my way for this place, nor would I wait more than 20 minutes tops to sit down.
Pros: Service, Fun ambience, Great for picky eaters - lots of toppings to choose from
Cons: too much hype, the food was good but just average
more