I've had great lunches from Totaro's. It's near my office and we order from a couple times a week. They just opened a dining room for dinner and we finally made it over after work last week. The chicken val d'asta was great and my friend had the snapper which was also delicious.
Pros: Food, staff, owners
Cons: Not good for a large group, but they did mention they'll rent the room if your
more