I have visited JC's many times and I've been happy every time. Even on New Years Eve 2003 service was great. Expect a wait on weekend nights though.
Try the Bowtie Festival. It's bowtie pasta with a creamy sauce with a hint of smokey flavor. It also has bacon and chicken. It's my favorite entree.
JC's pizzas haven't impressed me though. Nothing out of the ordinary or special when it comes to the pizzas.
Pros: service, menu selection, hearty portion size
Cons: , location
more