I recently ate at the Carlyle with my wife and another couple for Valentine's Day. The dimlit lights and candlelit tables make the atmosphere enjoyable and soothing. The service is great. I don't know if it was because it was V-Day or not, but the selection on the menu was somewhat small. But none the less the lamb shank I ordered was excellent. Surprisingly a dinner for two with tips and drinks came to well under a $100. The Raspberry Limeanade is a must have drink.
Pros: atmosphere, value
more