My largest complaint with the Newtown is that I remember it when... but the last two times I tried to go see a show there, I had to leave before the final curtain with a nasty sinus/allergic reaction. but heck, with the big Chain theaters being what they are- I buy gift certificates now and then just to 'support' the idea of a mom and pop theater.
Pros: cheap, in town, intimate
Cons: a bit dank, dusty
more