We made the short trip from Squirrel Hill into Oakland to visit this place. After double-checking that the car was locked, we went in and were a bit disappointed by the selection. The cinnamon ice cream is really good though. The bit of chocolate in the bottom of the cone is a nice touch. (It used to be marshmallow, maybe I missed it?)
However, we like Mineo's Ice Cream on Murray Ave, Squirrel Hill better. They have more interesting variety and it is the cheapest good ice cream anywhere ($1.50 for single scoop).
Pros: cinammon ice cream, cones
Cons: selection, service
more