I've visited hundreds of brewpubs across the US. The Herkimer easily produces and sells(!) the worst beer I've ever tasted.
I'm not sure you can even call it beer. If you've ever homebrewed yourself, the Herk beer is similar to what is produced after initial fermentation--cloudy, unrefined and uncarbonated. You'll also get a nice headache caused by the yeast floating through the beer...lovely. If you enjoy real beer, stay away from the Herkimer until they learn some basic homebrewing techniques.
Pros: Nice location
Cons: Horrible beer
more