The Gatsby

Claim
marker

712 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
Islip, NY 11751

marker
(631) 581-1900
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 3 )

Best

always curious since hearing about the beautiful the decor and the wonderful ambience. Though nothing could compare to the to the meal which was pure excellance. This truly was a...

Worst

The restaurant no longer exists.

The Gatsby closed several years ago. 11/18/2013

The restaurant no longer exists. more

The Gatsby closed several years ago. 11/18/2013

thomasc2 Provided by Partner
The restaurant no longer exists. more

THIS PLACE IS SOOO GROSSS 10/26/2009

I have never had a more disgusting dinner in my life, someone recommended the PORK dish and was tougher than a paver. I also heard the place was going out of business so beware! Pros: THERE ISNT ANY Cons: THE FOOD IS DISGUSTING more

Excellent food 1/29/2007

I thought this place had a great menu selection and the decor and service was wonderful. Definetly a great place for a date. more

easily the greatest restaurant around! 12/27/2006

always curious since hearing about the beautiful the decor and the wonderful ambience. Though nothing could compare to the to the meal which was pure excellance. This truly was a perfect dining experiance. I love dining out and trying new places but never have I been so impressed. Long Island restaurants are all too often disappointing. Theres so much to love about the Gatsby but the food is definately the main attraction. Pros: beautiful and romantic, excellant food and service, big bar and homemade desserts Cons: one of the appetizers was rather small more

Very Romantic & Awesome Food! 7/23/2006

This restaurant is awesome! If you are looking for a beautiful and romantic setting this it. The food is fabulous. And the service is exceptional. Definitely give this place a try. thegatsby.co m more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for The Gatsby


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Additional information
  • Hours: Tue - Fri 11:30-3:00, : Tue-Thur 4:00-10:00, Fri till 11:00, Sat 5:00-11:00, Sun 2:00-9:00
  • Neighborhoods: Islandia, Long Island City, Long Island
badge