On a recent scuba trip we selected prodiver out of Kihei, Maui and it was a great choice. The pros: just a 15 minute boat ride to Molokini, a 6 person boat, a dive master that's knowledgeble but forgiving for divers that may scuba infrequently or need some handholding, they refer to themselves as a "valet dive boat" meaning they check and secure all your equipment making for a relaxing experience, and they are flexible with their itinerary based on the boats' interests and skill levels. All in all, I highly recommend this dive company for a great scuba day trip.
more