Nicky Blaine's is well known, and pretty well reviewed online. The selection of martinis, scotch, and cigars is great. And, the lounge has a classy feel. Nevertheless, many of my friends who live in Indy told me to stay away from the place. They told me that it was overpriced and that the waiters and bartenders were jerks. I thought: they are probably basing their opinion on one isolated occurrence. Unfortunately, I was wrong. I just visited the establishment with 10 people. We were dressed very nicely. We were not intoxicated. We just wanted to have a few drinks. After paying $5 to get in, and getting a few pretentious stares from the manager, a man took our order. We each ordered a drink, and some in our party paid separately. It took 25 minutes for us to receive the drinks. The drinks were very overpriced for Indy ($8 and up). But, everyone was enjoying the environment, so we wanted another round. I looked at our waiter, and he ignored me. Finally, he approached us and told us that one member of our group "...Did not tip me enough. So, I'm done. You all brought him, so no drinks for any of you." I was astounded. I have never in my life been spoken to like that. I responded: "Sir, please, I tipped you an adequate amount. I have always tipped waiters a minimum of 15 to 20%, and I would like to be able to order another drink. I had nothing to do with the level of tip that my friend gave to you. Can I please have another drink?" He replied: "F**k you. I already said no. Ask again, and I'll ask you to leave." Upon hearing this, I approached the manager, who angrily informed me that he "backs the staff. It's the principle of the matter. Tip or get the f**k out!" I explained to him that I would not cause trouble, and would leave the bar. But, I would tell everyone I could to stay away from this place. He laughed out loud. Well, who's got the last laugh sir?
Pros: Great atmosphere, good music, martinis and cigars
Cons: Rude bartenders, rude waiters, rude doormen
more