Hilton Garden Inn New York/Staten Island - Staten Island Hotels

I stayed in this Hilton a while back. Other than the Hilton and the Staten Island hotel there are no other nice hotels on SI. I think the Hilton is more fancy. I stayed in a king romm that had a whirlpool in it. I thought that the room was very nice. I do not remember much about this hotel so I will not write a big review. Pros: whirlpool in the room. in the middle of no where so it is great to get away from it all. Cons: was very pricey more

This is the WORST Hilton I've ever stayed at. Save your sanity-- stay at the Staten Island Hotel. At least there's some life around it. The Garden Inn is completely isolated from civilisation. Staff are incapable of taking care of the most ordinary of tasks. They gave me the wrong departure time on the ferry, so I missed my train home! They don't know anything about public transit on the island. The manager was supposed to call me and never did. The workout room is attached to the pool, so you breathe chlorine fumes while you're trying to be healthy. You're forced to eat pricey mediocre food because there's nowhere else within 10 miles! I spent 10 hellish days there for work and I'm still recovering. Pros: housekeeping staff Cons: incompetant staff, location, workout room more